WNPR

Trump Administration's Latest Strike On CFPB: Budget Cuts

Feb 18, 2018
Originally published on February 21, 2018 12:01 pm

The Trump administration is proposing to dramatically cut funding for the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, a move critics say is an ongoing assault on the 7-year-old agency.

The bureau was championed by Elizabeth Warren and other Democrats and created in the wake of the financial crisis to protect Americans from getting ripped off by financial firms.

The White House proposal would chop funding for the CFPB by about $150 million — or a quarter of its budget. Such cuts would mean "massive layoffs and disruptions," says Mike Calhoun, the president of the Center for Responsible Lending. That would "make it hard for it to do its job — a job that it's been doing incredibly well," he says.

Financial watchdog groups such as Calhoun's say the agency has been paying for itself many times over. Part of its mission is to go after companies that swindle consumers to get people their money back, "so far returning over $12 billion in relief to consumers who were treated illegally by financial companies," Calhoun says. So in that sense, the CFPB is returning far more money to taxpayers than it's costing them.

But some Republicans think the bureau is too powerful and has been too aggressive in crafting new regulations and suing financial firms. And President Trump appointed one of the agency's harshest critics to be its interim director.

As a congressman, Mick Mulvaney sponsored legislation to abolish the CFPB, and he still doesn't speak very highly of the agency he's leading. Speaking on CBS' Face the Nation, Mulvaney said the CFPB "has no accountability to Congress. It is perhaps the most unaccountable bureau or agency there is."

He said he wants to run the agency "with a good deal of humility and prudence." But critics say Mulvaney is not being humble, he's being reckless.

Under Mulvaney, the bureau has put on hold new regulations for high-interest payday lenders. And it's dropped an investigation into a a payday lender that contributed to Mulvaney's campaign when he was in Congress. Mulvaney has said he doesn't think those contributions create a conflict of interest.

And now Mulvaney has proposed steep budget cuts. He says he's not "gutting" the agency, but Democrats vow they won't take the move sitting down.

"We will fight any effort to defund the CFPB," says Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md. Van Hollen pressed Mulvaney in a hearing this week about the agency head's decision to drop a lawsuit against an online lender called Golden Valley. The lawsuit said the lender is charging illegal and predatory interest rates.

Van Hollen: "950 percent interest rates. ... this is higher than Mafia loan sharks. Were you part of the decision to drop the case against Golden Valley?"

Mulvaney: "Yes sir."

Van Hollen: "I'll follow up with that. I think it's an outrageous decision."

Van Hollen says an NPR report this week prompted him to start looking into the lender. That report said Mulvaney dropped the lawsuit even though the entire professional career staff at the bureau wanted to press ahead with the case.

Van Hollen says he wants a full accounting from Mulvaney about why he did that. "It's pretty clear right now, if left to their own devices, Mulvany and the Trump administration will essentially turn the keys to the agency over to the very people who are cheating consumers," Van Hollen says.

The CFPB gets its funding from the Federal Reserve, not Congress. But if Mulvaney tries to slash its budget, Mike Calhoun of the Center for Responsible Lending says Congress could act to block the move.

Polls show that the CFPB is popular with voters of both parties. So Calhoun says some Republicans might join Democrats to protect the agency.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

MICHEL MARTIN, HOST:

The Trump administration wants to dramatically cut funding for the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. That's the agency created after the financial crisis to protect Americans from abuse by financial firms. Elizabeth Warren and other Democrats have strongly defended the agency. And now critics say the administration's move is just the latest in an ongoing assault on the young agency. NPR's Chris Arnold has the story.

CHRIS ARNOLD, BYLINE: The Trump administration says it wants to chop funding for the Consumer Protection Bureau by about $150 million or a quarter of its budget. That would be a disaster says Mike Calhoun. He's with the Center for Responsible Lending. He says the cuts would mean...

MIKE CALHOUN: Massive layoffs and disruptions and make it hard for it to do its job, a job that it's been doing incredibly well.

ARNOLD: Calhoun and other financial watchdog groups say the bureau has been paying for itself many times over. That's because part of its mission is to go after companies that swindle consumers and to get people their money back.

CALHOUN: So far, returning over $12 billion in relief to consumers who were treated illegally by financial companies.

ARNOLD: But some Republicans think that the bureau has too much power and that it's been using it to sue financial firms and strongarm settlements out of them, as well as being too aggressive in crafting new regulations. And at President Trump has now appointed one of the agency's harshest critics to be its interim director. As a congressman, Mick Mulvaney sponsored legislation to abolish the CFP. Now he's in charge there, and he doesn't speak very highly of the agency he's now leading. Here's Mulvaney on CBS's "Face The Nation."

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, "FACE THE NATION")

MICK MULVANEY: This bureau is unlike any other federal bureaucracy. It had almost unlimited access to funds. It has no accountability to Congress. It is perhaps the most unaccountable bureau or agency there is. We want to run that place with a good deal of humility and prudence.

ARNOLD: But critics say Mulvaney's not being humble, he's being reckless. Under his leadership, the bureau's put on hold new regulations for high interest what are called payday lenders. And it's dropped an investigation into a payday lender that contributed to Mulvaney's campaign when he was in Congress. Mulvaney has said he doesn't think those contributions create a conflict of interest. Now, Mulvaney has proposed these steep budget cuts, which Democrats say they won't take sitting down.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

CHRIS VAN HOLLEN: We will fight any effort to defund the CFPB.

ARNOLD: That's Democratic Senator Chris Van Hollen. He pressed Mulvaney at a hearing this week about Mulvaney's decision to drop a lawsuit against an online lender. The lawsuit said the lender, called Golden Valley, charges illegal predatory interest rates.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

VAN HOLLEN: Nine hundred and fifty percent interest rates. I mean, this is higher than the mafia loan sharks. Were you part of the decision to drop the case against Golden Valley?

MULVANEY: Yes, sir.

VAN HOLLEN: OK. I'll follow up with that. I think it's an outrageous decision.

ARNOLD: Van Hollen says a report on NPR about Mulvaney dropping the lawsuit prompted him to start digging into complaints about the lender. NPR reported that Mulvaney dropped the lawsuit even though the entire professional career staff at the bureau wanted to press ahead with it. Van Hollen now says he wants a full accounting from Mulvaney about why he did that.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

VAN HOLLEN: It's pretty clear right now if, left to their own devices, Mulvaney and the Trump administration will essentially turn the keys to the agencies over to the very people who are cheating consumers.

ARNOLD: As far as the proposed budget cuts, the agency gets its funding from the Federal Reserve, not Congress. But if Mulvaney tries to slash its budget, Mike Calhoun says Congress could act to block the move. Polls show that the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is popular with voters of both parties, so he says some Republicans might join Democrats to protect the agency. Chris Arnold, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.