WNPR

After Maria, Puerto Rico Struggles Under The Weight Of Its Own Garbage

Dec 14, 2017
Originally published on December 15, 2017 11:15 am

Outside Puerto Rico's capital, a three-story-high mountain of debris and waste sits smack in the middle of what was a suburban soccer field before Hurricane Maria devastated the island.

Blue bleachers peek out from the edge of the trash pile, as a line of trucks rolls in to dump even more tree branches and moldy furniture. Workmen wearing yellow hard hats operate diggers to add the new waste to the growing pile in the center of the field.

Puerto Rico is struggling under the weight of its own garbage. Even before Maria hit in September, the Environmental Protection Agency says, most of the island's landfills were filled beyond capacity and that nearly half were under orders to close.

Puerto Rico's Solid Waste Authority estimates that the powerful hurricane created 6.2 million cubic yards of waste and debris. That's enough trash to fill about 43 football stadiums with piles of waste eight stories high, according to a measure used by FEMA.

And it has to go somewhere.

Workmen at the soccer field say the site became a makeshift dump because the landfill for the Toa Baja municipality, near San Juan, is so flooded with trash that wait times to dump debris can be hours. When the soccer site becomes too full, the workers say waste is then moved to the landfill in trucks.

In Maria's wake, local governments are supposed to separate tree branches and other "green waste" for composting so that it doesn't clog up landfills, says Antonio Rios, head of the Solid Waste Authority, the agency that sets the U.S. territory's waste policy.

That composting process isn't happening everywhere, Rios acknowledges. Green debris is still winding up in overflowing landfills across the island, though he says authorities are trying to divert additional material to landfills that have more room. Rios points out that the hurricane also has created other types of waste, things like broken kitchen appliances and food that went rotten because of a lack of electricity.

The landfill in Toa Baja is managed by the private firm Conwaste and takes in trash from at least four municipalities. It has been deeply troubled for years.

The site is supervised by 25-year-old Lionel Ruiz. Last month, he says, it accepted 36,000 tons of waste — that's 70 percent more than the month before the hurricane. Ruiz points to trash-filled trucks waiting in a line that stretches down a dirt road and off into the distance.

"It's more busy than usual," Ruiz says. "You see the line? We never have that line in normal operation."

In 2008, the EPA ordered the Toa Baja landfill to close by 2014 because it posed an "imminent and substantial endangerment to health and the environment." The agency said environmental inspectors found evidence that the landfill did not have a system to control liquid seeping through the garbage pile and into the ground. The agency found that this substance, called leachate, could potentially contaminate a nearby aquifer and wetlands.

In 2012, the EPA permitted the landfill to delay the closure for an unspecified amount of time. It was also allowed to create a smaller area incorporating more environmental precautions — such as a lining to prevent seepage — and begin accepting waste there.

The problems are much the same across the lush tropical island of Puerto Rico. The EPA got directly involved in the island's landfills in 2002, and has since ordered at least 12 of the approximately 29 landfills to close, which can be a years-long process.

It's not immediately clear how many sites — most of which are already at capacity — have actually shut down.

Rios of the Solid Waste Authority estimates that at current recycling rates, all of the island's landfills will be full in 20 to 25 years.

Even the newly added space in Toa Baja's landfill is rapidly filling up, Ruiz says. Before the hurricane hit, he said he thought it would take five years for that area to fill up; Maria has sped up the timeline.

And he's grappling with immediate problems. Birds and insects circle around what is currently a hot, rancid, open dump.

"This is the active area of the landfill, you will see a lot of uncovered material," Ruiz says. Workers would normally cover the expansive mess with earth every day to comply with federal regulations, but he says they haven't been able to do so for a week because the private trucks they use are now being used by FEMA.

The uncovered mounds of rotting garbage is upsetting to people down the hill in the neighborhood of Candelaria, people like 83-year-old Angelo Fernandez. "The smell, the stink!" he says, totally exasperated. "Every time they leave it open, the smell is awful."

In his 41 years living here, he's seen mountains of trash rise from the ground, parts of which are now covered with dirt and vegetation. But the waste lies just inches under the surface.

"It is getting bigger, it is getting bigger and bigger — that was never this height — never," Fernandez says. "All that mountain you see there is garbage!"

He says people living in Candelaria suffer from asthma and other breathing problems because of the landfill. They cough a lot.

Actually closing a landfill is expensive, costing approximately $200,000 per acre, according to Rios. Puerto Rico is struggling with more than $120 billion in debt and pension obligations, and has filed for a bankruptcy-like procedure — and that was before the hurricane.

The EPA has acknowledged that the budget crisis is making it more difficult for local governments on the island to handle the garbage problem. The municipalities "have always had limited funds to implement the environmental and engineering controls required to improve, and ultimately close, the landfills," the agency says. And Puerto Rico's Environmental Quality Board hasn't required municipalities to set money aside in case their landfills needed to close.

Another issue, Rios says, is that some of the landfills now under closure orders aren't charging garbage trucks high enough fees to generate the money to actually shut down.

Ultimately, the troubled landfill system is "a public health issue and it's about to collapse really soon," says Agustín Carbo Lugo, former head of the Solid Waste Authority. He says Puerto Rico also needs to think beyond landfills rather than just open new ones. Recycling rates on the island are about half of what they are on the U.S. mainland.

"We need to look for different alternatives," he says, particularly because Puerto Rico has limited space. That might include a number of other waste management techniques such as "waste-to-energy," which uses methods like incineration to produce electricity and heat.

Most importantly, Carbo Lugo says, "people need to change their behavior and it's quite complex, how you change that in a small island. But it can be done — it just, people need to understand what's at stake here."

Those stakes are clear to Fernandez, who lives next to the landfill. He says that if it closed for good, "I think it would be a better place to live. I know it would be."

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

Puerto Rico is struggling with too much trash. Even before Hurricane Maria hit most of the island's landfills were filled beyond capacity. And the debris and waste from the hurricane have only made the problem worse. NPR's Merrit Kennedy reports.

MERRIT KENNEDY, BYLINE: Outside the capital, San Juan, a suburban soccer field has been transformed into an improvised dump site. Bleachers peek out from the edge of the trash.

Trucks are rolling in. They're filled with debris, tree branches, moldy mattresses. I can see a pink kid's suitcase being unloaded onto a massive pile of garbage in the center of the field. And it's probably about three stories high.

Workmen say this site came to be because the actual landfill is so busy. The wait time can be hours. Just up the road, 25-year-old Lionel Ruiz is the supervisor of that municipal landfill in Toa Baja. He says that last month, they accepted 36,000 tons of waste. That's 70 percent more than the month before the hurricane. Ruiz points to the trucks waiting to dump.

LIONEL RUIZ: It's more busy that usual. You see that line? We never have that line in normal operation.

KENNEDY: Trash from at least four municipalities comes to the landfill, and it already had huge problems before the hurricane. In 2008, the Environmental Protection Agency ordered it to close because of environmental risks. Since then, the landfill was allowed to open a new area with a lining to prevent seepage into the ground. But that space is rapidly filling up.

RUIZ: It's near to get full maybe in five year.

KENNEDY: That was Ruiz's estimate before the hurricane, and Maria has sped up the timeline. The story is the same across the lush tropical island of Puerto Rico. Before the hurricane, the EPA had ordered 12 of its approximately 29 landfills to close.

AGUSTIN CARBO: It's a public health issue. And it's about to collapse really soon.

KENNEDY: That's Agustin Carbo. He's the former head of the island's Solid Waste Authority and says Puerto Rico needs to think beyond landfills rather than open new ones. Recycling rates here are about half of what they are on the U.S. mainland.

CARBO: We need to look for different alternatives. I think people need to change their behavior. And it's quite complex how you change that in a small island. But it can be done. People need to understand what's at stake here.

KENNEDY: Back at the landfill, Ruiz is facing very immediate problems. Birds and insects circle around what is currently a hot, rancid open dump.

RUIZ: This is the active area of the landfill. You will see a lot of uncovered material.

KENNEDY: Workers here would normally cover this expansive mess with earth every day to comply with federal regulations. Ruiz says they haven't been able to for a week because the private trucks they usually use are contracted with FEMA. The open garbage is upsetting to people who live down the hill, like 83-year-old Angelo Fernandez.

ANGELO FERNANDEZ: The smell. The stink (laughter).

KENNEDY: In his 41 years living here, he's seen a mountain rise from the ground.

FERNANDEZ: It is getting bigger. It is getting bigger and bigger. That was never this high - never. All the mountains you see there, that's garbage.

KENNEDY: What would it mean to you if it closed?

FERNANDEZ: I think it would be a better place to live. I know. And people, they would get less sick.

KENNEDY: The landfill may be filling up, but it's not clear when it will actually shut down. The EPA hasn't set a hard date. Merrit Kennedy, NPR News, Toa Baja, Puerto Rico. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.